One of the things I found interesting when I learned more about Canadian traditions was the timing of Thanksgiving. Unlike in the United States, where Thanksgiving is celebrated in November, Canada’s Thanksgiving falls on the second Monday of October.
Yes, October! And if you’re wondering why, just as I did, you’re not alone.
My first thought was that it had something to do with the weather.

Canada has a shorter autumn season in many parts of the country, and perhaps Thanksgiving is celebrated earlier to make the most of the warmer days before winter arrives.
Well, I wasn’t entirely wrong, but there’s more to the story.
As someone experiencing Thanksgiving in Canada, I became curious about why two neighbouring countries celebrate what seems to be the same holiday almost six weeks apart. Is it simply about the harvest? Is it rooted in history? Or is it one of those traditions that evolved differently on either side of the border?
As it turns out, the Canadian Thanksgiving story is quite interesting.
Why Does Canada Celebrate Thanksgiving in October?
The short answer is that Canadian Thanksgiving is closely associated with the autumn harvest, which generally takes place earlier in the year than in many parts of the United States.
But the date wasn’t always the second Monday in October.
Canadian Thanksgiving has gone through several changes over the years. Early thanksgiving ceremonies in what is now Canada were held for different reasons, including giving thanks for safe journeys, peace, military victories, and significant royal events.
One often-mentioned early celebration took place in 1578, when English explorer Martin Frobisher and his crew held a ceremony of thanksgiving after reaching what is now Canada’s North Atlantic region. It was an expression of gratitude for their safe passage, rather than the annual harvest celebration we associate with Thanksgiving today.
In 1879, Thanksgiving became an annual national observance, initially celebrated on November 6. Its date continued to change over the following decades, sometimes falling in October and sometimes in November.
Finally, on January 31, 1957, the Canadian government officially established the second Monday in October as Thanksgiving Day. The proclamation described it as a day of general thanksgiving for the bountiful harvest with which Canada had been blessed.

The October date also aligned more closely with the completion of the harvest in many parts of the country and kept Thanksgiving separate from Remembrance Day, observed on November 11.
So, my weather theory wasn’t entirely off the mark after all! The seasonal timing and the harvest both played a part, although the holiday’s history is more complicated than simply celebrating before winter sets in.
Canadian Thanksgiving vs. American Thanksgiving
Although Canada and the United States share many Thanksgiving traditions, the holidays have different histories and dates.
The American Thanksgiving is commonly associated with the 1621 harvest gathering at Plymouth, Massachusetts, involving English settlers and the Wampanoag people. This gathering is often presented as an important part of the American Thanksgiving story, although Indigenous peoples’ traditions of giving thanks and celebrating the harvest existed long before European settlement.
In the United States, Thanksgiving became a national annual holiday during the Civil War. President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national day of thanksgiving in 1863, and the date eventually became the fourth Thursday of November.
Canada followed a different path. Its national Thanksgiving observances developed through a series of proclamations and celebrations, and the date was not fixed until 1957.
Here’s a quick comparison:
| Canadian Thanksgiving | American Thanksgiving | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Second Monday in October | Fourth Thursday in November |
| Main seasonal connection | Autumn harvest | Autumn harvest |
| Annual national observance | Established in 1879 | National annual observance proclaimed in 1863 |
| Common traditions | Family meals, turkey, harvest foods, giving thanks | Family meals, turkey, football, parades, giving thanks |
| Shopping season | Not traditionally the major shopping event | Closely associated with Black Friday shopping |
Despite their different dates and histories, both celebrations share a familiar theme: taking time to appreciate what we have and spending time with the people who matter.
What Are Canadian Thanksgiving Traditions?
For many Canadians, Thanksgiving is an opportunity to gather with family and friends, enjoy a home-cooked meal, and appreciate the beauty of the autumn season.
The traditional Thanksgiving table often includes roast turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, and seasonal vegetables. Pumpkin pie is also a familiar dessert.
Of course, not every household celebrates in exactly the same way. Some families prepare ham instead of turkey, others bring their own cultural food traditions to the table, and some prefer a simple meal or a weekend getaway.
The long weekend also gives people an opportunity to enjoy the changing colours of autumn. Across many parts of Canada, October is a beautiful time to take a drive, visit a park, go apple picking, or simply enjoy the crisp autumn air before the colder months arrive.
And perhaps that’s one of the things I find interesting about Canadian Thanksgiving: it is not only about the meal. It is also about the season and the opportunity to pause before the busier winter months begin.
Thanksgiving in a Multicultural Canada
One thing worth remembering is that Canada is a multicultural country, and not everyone grew up celebrating Thanksgiving in the same way.
For newcomers, the holiday can be an opportunity to learn about Canadian traditions while also bringing their own cultural backgrounds into the celebration.
A Thanksgiving dinner doesn’t necessarily have to look like the one in a magazine. It could be turkey alongside rice, a family recipe from another country, or a potluck where everyone brings a dish that reminds them of home.
For me, this is one of the lovely things about living in a multicultural society. Traditions can be shared, adapted, and given new meaning without necessarily losing the stories and memories that make them special.
Thanksgiving may have a particular historical background in Canada, but the simple act of gathering around a table and appreciating one another is something that people from different cultures can understand.
It also reminds us that gratitude doesn’t have to be expressed in just one language, through one type of food, or according to one particular tradition.
A Little Reminder to Be Thankful
I think we sometimes need a reminder to slow down and appreciate the things we might otherwise take for granted.
Life gets busy. We become occupied with work, responsibilities, plans, and the endless list of things we still want to accomplish. Sometimes, we forget to acknowledge how far we’ve come and the people who have been part of our journey.
Whether it’s a family dinner, a quiet afternoon, a phone call with someone we miss, or simply enjoying the beautiful colours of autumn, there are plenty of little things worth appreciating.
And while Thanksgiving is celebrated on different dates in Canada and the United States, I suppose the meaning behind it doesn’t have to be tied to a particular month or calendar day.
You don’t need a turkey dinner or a holiday gathering to give thanks. You can do that any day of the year.
Perhaps that’s what I appreciate most about the idea of Thanksgiving. Beyond the history, the food, and the traditions, it offers a simple reminder to pause, look around, and be grateful for what we have.
Whether you’re celebrating Canadian Thanksgiving in October, American Thanksgiving in November, or simply taking a moment to appreciate the good things in your life, there’s always a reason to give thanks.
Con mucho amor,
Imelda ♥
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why does Canada celebrate Thanksgiving in October instead of November?
Canadian Thanksgiving is associated with the autumn harvest, which generally takes place earlier in Canada. The second Monday in October was officially established as Thanksgiving Day in 1957.
2. When is Canadian Thanksgiving celebrated?
Canadian Thanksgiving is observed on the second Monday of October every year.
3. Is Canadian Thanksgiving older than American Thanksgiving?
Thanksgiving ceremonies took place in what is now Canada before the well-known 1621 gathering at Plymouth. However, the two countries developed their national Thanksgiving observances differently. Canada’s annual national observance dates to 1879, while the United States proclaimed a national annual Thanksgiving observance in 1863.
4. What is the difference between Canadian and American Thanksgiving?
The main differences are their dates and historical development. Canada celebrates on the second Monday in October, while the United States celebrates on the fourth Thursday in November.
5. What do Canadians eat on Thanksgiving?
Common foods include roast turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, seasonal vegetables, and pumpkin pie. Family menus vary according to regional and cultural traditions.
6. Is Canadian Thanksgiving a harvest festival?
Canadian Thanksgiving is historically associated with giving thanks for the autumn harvest. Today, it is also an occasion for family gatherings, gratitude, and togetherness.
7. Do all Canadians celebrate Thanksgiving?
No. Customs and participation vary among individuals, families, and cultural communities. Some observe the holiday with traditional meals, while others incorporate their own cultural traditions or do not celebrate it.
8. Why is Canadian Thanksgiving celebrated on a Monday?
The second Monday in October creates a long weekend, giving many Canadians an opportunity to spend time with family and friends.